Proposal (108) to South American Classification Committee
Change English name of Leptotila megalura
Effect on South American CL: This proposal would change the
English name of a species on our list from a "Meyer de Schauensee"
name ("Large-tailed Dove") to a "Goodwin-HBW" name
("White-faced Dove").
Background: Meyer de Schauensee (1966, 1970) used the
name "Large-tailed Dove" for Leptotila megalura, and this
has been followed by essentially all literature, except for Goodwin (1983), who
used "White-faced Dove." Baptista et al. (1997) also followed this.
Gibbs et al. (2001) Mazar Barnett & Pearman (2001) invented yet another
name, "Yungas Dove," which is probably the "best" of the three.
Analysis: Although "Large-tailed" is presumably useless in the
field, it is accurate and has 30+ years of historical momentum. It is used in
Olrog (1984), Narosky & Yzurieta (1987), Remsen & Traylor (1989), De la
Peña & Rumboll (1998), and Hennessey et al. (2003).
Recommendation: I vote NO on this proposal. I see no point in
using a new name. [If someone wants to do another proposal to change to
"Yungas Dove," go ahead.]
Literature Cited:
BAPTISTA,
L. F., P. W. TRAIL, AND H. M. HORBLIT. 1997. Family Columbidae (pigeons and
doves). Pp. 60-243 in "Handbook of the Birds of the World, Vol. 4.
Sandgrouse to cuckoos." (J. del Hoyo et al., eds.). Lynx Edicions,
Barcelona.
DE LA PEÑA,
M. R., AND M. RUMBOLL. 1998. Birds of Southern South America and Antarctica. .
Harper Collins.
GIBBS, D.,
E. BARNES, AND J. COX. 2001. Pigeons and doves. Yale University Press, New
Haven.
GOODWIN, D.
1983. Pigeons and doves of the world, 3rd ed. Cornell Univ. Press, Ithaca, New
York.
HENNESSEY,
A. B, S. K. HERZOG, AND F. SAGOT. 2003. Lista anotada de las Aves de Bolivia. Asociación
Armonía/Birdlife International, Santa Cruz, Bolivia.
MAZAR
BARNETT, J., AND M. PEARMAN. 2001. Annotated checklist of the birds of
Argentina. Lynx Edicions, Barcelona.
MEYER DE
SCHAUENSEE, R. 1966. The species of birds of South America and their
distribution. Livingston Publishing Co., Narberth, Pennsylvania.
MEYER DE
SCHAUENSEE, R. 1970. A guide to the birds of South America. Livingston
Publishing Co., Wynnewood, Pennsylvania.
NAROSKY,
T., AND D. YZURIETA. 1993. Birds of Argentina & Uruguay. A Field Guide. Asociación Ornitologica Del
Plata, Buenos Aires.
OLROG, C.
C. 1984. Las Aves Argentinas. Administración
Parques Nacionales, Buenos
Aires.
Van Remsen, March 2004
____________________________________________________________________________________________
Comments from Stiles: "NO. Once again, if we start
to get into the business of tinkering with English names, substituting every
time a slightly better one comes along, we'll never finish. The old, accepted
name isn´t inaccurate, so I see no reason to change it."
Comments from Nores: "NO, el nombre es apropiado y de alguna utilidad en el campo."
Comments from Jaramillo: "NO. No reason to do this, particularly since
White-faced Dove is not really a useful name either. Now if the choice had been
Yungas Dove, I do think I would have jumped at that one. I do not feel strongly
enough to write a proposal for this, and given my general concern with name
stability, I think I would just be falling into the trap of trying to improve
English names and get into the tinkering that Gary mentions."
Comments from Zimmer: "NO. For reasons outlined in
my votes on #106 and #107."