Proposal (20) to South American Classification Committee
Change of English
name for Podiceps taczanowskii
Background.
Called
'Puna Grebe' as first used by Meyer de Schauensee (1966) and most subsequent
authors. 'Junin Flightless Grebe' was proposed by Fjeldså and Krabbe (1990) to
emphasize its flightlessness.
Comments.
Publications
(6) by ICBP/BirdLife International now call it 'Junin Grebe' (see references).
Conclusions.
The
species is endemic to Lake Junín, so 'Junín Grebe' is a very good name as this
is also the name used in Spanish: Zambullidor de Junín. As other species of
grebes also live in the 'puna,' 'Junin Grebe' would be very specific. There is
aprecedence on the name change of a grebe due to its restricted range. In
Guatemala Podilymbus gigas name was
changed from Giant Pied-billed Grebe to Atitlán Grebe, because it was only
known from Lake Atitlán.
Proposal.
I
propose that the name be changed to Junín Grebe as it is very specific as to
its present distribution.
References.
Meyer de
Schauensee, Rodolphe. 1966. The species of birds of South America and their
distribution. Livingston Publishing Company, Narberth, Pennsylvania, p. 11.
Collar,
Nigel J., and Paul Andrew, (Eds.) 1988. Birds to watch: the ICBP world
checklist of threatened birds. Intern. Council Bird Preserv. Tech. Bull., no.
8: 6, 241.
Fjeldså,
Jon, and Niels Krabbe. 1990. Birds of the high Andes. A manual to the birds of
the temperate zone of the Andes and Patagonia, South America. Zool. Museum,
Univ. Copenhagen, pp. 66-67.
Collar,
Nigel J., Michael J. Crosby, and Alison J. Stattersfield. 1994. Birds to watch
2: the world list of threatened birds. BirdLife Conserv. Ser., no. 4: 31-32,
311.
Collar,
Nigel J., Luis P. Gonzaga, Niels Krabbe, Alberto Madroño Nieto, Luis J.
Naranjo, Theodore A. Parker III, and David C. Wege. 1992. Threatened birds of
the Americas: the ICBP/IUCN Red Data Book. 3rd edition, Part 2. International
Council for Bird Preservation, Cambridge, England, pp. 43-47.
Wege,
David C., and Adrian J. Long. 1995. Key areas for threatened birds in the
Neotropics. BirdLife Conserv. Ser., no. 5: 242, 290
Stattersfield,
Alison J., Michael J. Crosby, Adrian J. Long, and David C. Wege. 1997. Endemic
bird areas of the world: priorities for biodiversity conservation. BirdLife
Conser. Ser. no. 7: 227, 680.
BirdLife
International. 2000. Threatened birds of the world. Lynx Editions and BirdLife
International, Barcelona and Cambridge, UK, p. 45.
Manuel A. Plenge, 20 June 2002
________________________________________________________________________________________
From
Mark Robbins:
"I vote "yes" for both of Manuel's proposals. Both proposed
names are far more informative than their current English names."
From Tom
Schulenberg:
"With regard to Proposal 20, English name change of Podiceps taczanowskii
from Puna Grebe to Junin Grebe, I vote YES.
"I
usually prefer to retain established names, but for this species,
"Puna" is an odd (less appropriate) choice, and since
"Junin" rapidly is becoming entrenched as "the" established
name, I can go along with the substitution. "
From
Gary Stiles:
"I much prefer toponyms for geographically restricted birds, as it calls
attention to their small ranges (On the other hand, I don’t go much for naming
widespread birds from their type localities - but I suppose it’s 'way too late
to do in Philadelphia Vireo or Tennessee Warbler..)."
From
Alvaro Jaramillo:
"YES, Junin Grebe is a good change. It may cause some confusion with P.
occipitalis juninensis, but not enough to concern me. "