Proposal (489) to South American Classification Committee
Changes in various
species names to conform to The
Code
N. David and M.
Gosselin have done another paper (2011) on gender agreement of species group
names in birds, concentrating on words that could be either nouns or adjectives
(Code Art. 31.2.2). Results of their
study indicate that the spelling of five specific names of birds in the Americas
should be changed (if they now agree with Dickinson 2003) to conform to the
Code. These changes are because names
previously treated as nouns in apposition are really adjectives, or vice versa.
All five species
occur in South America; two are also in North America.
South America:
Aramides cajanea should be A. cajaneus
Porphyrio martinica should be P. martinicus
Amazona mercenaria should be A. mercenarius
Frederickena unduligera should be F. unduliger
Premnornis guttuligera should be P. guttuliger
North America:
Aramides cajanea should be A. cajaneus
Porphyrio martinica should be P. martinicus
Literature Cited
David, N., and M. Gosselin. 2011.
Gender agreement of avian species-group names under Article 31.2.2 of
the ICZN Code. Bull. Brit. Ornithol.
Club 131:103-115.
Dickinson, Edward.
2003. Howard and Moore Checklist
Richard C. Banks, June 2011
Comments from Nores: “YES. It is clear in the analysis made by David and Gosselin (2011) that the spelling of the specific names of these five species should be changed. However, there are a large number of South American birds, which are in a similar situation that should be analyzed. I will try to make a proposal about this subject.”
Comments from Stiles:
“YES - if the
pundits say so, it’s best to go along.”
Comments
from Pacheco:
“YES. Os autores apresentaram
razões plenamente afinadas com o ICZN.”
Comments from Zimmer: “YES, although am I the only one who is no longer sure what the Latin name of anything is, or what family half of the passerines are now in? Seems like a lifetime of learned nomenclature has gone out the window in a few short years, thanks to the need for gender agreement of species group names combine with the molecular revolution!”